The mistaken belief that arguments must be logically perfect to be valid—that any logical flaw, no matter how minor or irrelevant, invalidates the entire conclusion. This fallacy ignores that most real-world arguments are not formally perfect, yet still convey truth, persuade audiences, and guide action. The perfect logic fallacy is beloved of internet pedants who delight in pointing out irrelevant formal errors while ignoring the substantive point. It's the logic of "you committed a fallacy, therefore you're wrong," which confuses form with content. The cure is recognizing that logic is a tool, not a tyrant—useful for clarifying thought, not for dismissing it.
Perfect Logic Fallacy Example: "She made an argument about economic inequality. He pounced on a minor logical slip—irrelevant to her main point—and declared her entire argument invalid. The perfect logic fallacy had done its work: avoiding substance by seizing on form. She stopped engaging, which was probably what he wanted."
by Abzugal Nammugal Enkigal February 17, 2026
Get the Perfect Logic Fallacy mug.