Amish butter

The result of a handjob continued after orgasm. So-called because of the churned result from a low-technology method.

"Hey Mitch, you're walking kind of funny."
"Yes, I'm a bit sore after making Amish butter last night."

by DunkinGas June 25, 2022

Nutter butter

A nutter butter is almost like lube but made out of butter it is applied when you're about to have intercourse.

Wait let me apply some nutter butter.

by Kingsyrup February 17, 2022

BELLYBUTTON BUTTER

THIS IS THE JUICE'S THAT DRIP OUT OF YOUR INNIE BUTTON AFTER A MAN EJACULATES INTO IT

Last night I spread my bellybutton butter on my husband's toast

by THUGNASTY206 February 21, 2022

Peanut Butter Banana

When you put your penis in a butthole and pull it out, then you have a peanut butter banana

I asked my husband if I could put his peanut butter banana in my mouth after he got done hitting me from the back

by Fat Boy Marco March 1, 2022